Very quick one this!  Really interesting paper from Ioannidis et al about citation indices.

I wanted to recreate figure 1, which is:

journal.pbio.1002501.g001

Closest I could get (code here) is this:

plos_weird

Biggest difference is in NS, where they find all negative correlations, but most of mine are positive.

Source data are Table S1 Data.

Am I doing something wrong?  Or is the paper wrong?

 

UPDATE 9th July 2016

Using Spearman gets us closer but it’s still not quite correct (updated code too)

results_spearman